Ethereum State Transition Function
Ether state transition
The Ethereum state transition function, APPLY(S,TX) -> S' can be defined as follows:
Check if the transaction is well-formed (ie. has the right number of values), the signature is valid, and the nonce matches the nonce in the sender's account. If not, return an error.
Calculate the transaction fee as STARTGAS * GASPRICE, and determine the sending address from the signature. Subtract the fee from the sender's account balance and increment the sender's nonce. If there is not enough balance to spend, return an error.
Initialize GAS = STARTGAS, and take off a certain quantity of gas per byte to pay for the bytes in the transaction.
Transfer the transaction value from the sender's account to the receiving account. If the receiving account does not yet exist, create it. If the receiving account is a contract, run the contract's code either to completion or until the execution runs out of gas.
If the value transfer failed because the sender did not have enough money, or the code execution ran out of gas, revert all state changes except the payment of the fees, and add the fees to the miner's account.
Otherwise, refund the fees for all remaining gas to the sender, and send the fees paid for gas consumed to the miner.
For example, suppose that the contract's code is:
if !self.storage[calldataload(0)]:
self.storage[calldataload(0)] = calldataload(32)
Note that in reality the contract code is written in the low-level EVM code; this example is written in Serpent, one of our high-level languages, for clarity, and can be compiled down to EVM code. Suppose that the contract's storage starts off empty, and a transaction is sent with 10 ether value, 2000 gas, 0.001 ether gasprice, and 64 bytes of data, with bytes 0-31 representing the number 2 and bytes 32-63 representing the string CHARLIE.fn. 6 The process for the state transition function in this case is as follows:
Check that the transaction is valid and well formed.
Check that the transaction sender has at least 2000 * 0.001 = 2 ether. If it is, then subtract 2 ether from the sender's account.
Initialize gas = 2000; assuming the transaction is 170 bytes long and the byte-fee is 5, subtract 850 so that there is 1150 gas left.
Subtract 10 more ether from the sender's account, and add it to the contract's account.
Run the code. In this case, this is simple: it checks if the contract's storage at index 2 is used, notices that it is not, and so it sets the storage at index 2 to the value CHARLIE. Suppose this takes 187 gas, so the remaining amount of gas is 1150 - 187 = 963
Add 963 * 0.001 = 0.963 ether back to the sender's account, and return the resulting state.
If there was no contract at the receiving end of the transaction, then the total transaction fee would simply be equal to the provided GASPRICE multiplied by the length of the transaction in bytes, and the data sent alongside the transaction would be irrelevant.
Note that messages work equivalently to transactions in terms of reverts: if a message execution runs out of gas, then that message's execution, and all other executions triggered by that execution, revert, but parent executions do not need to revert. This means that it is "safe" for a contract to call another contract, as if A calls B with G gas then A's execution is guaranteed to lose at most G gas. Finally, note that there is an opcode, CREATE, that creates a contract; its execution mechanics are generally similar to CALL, with the exception that the output of the execution determines the code of a newly created contract.
Code Execution
The code in Ethereum contracts is written in a low-level, stack-based bytecode language, referred to as "Ethereum virtual machine code" or "EVM code". The code consists of a series of bytes, where each byte represents an operation. In general, code execution is an infinite loop that consists of repeatedly carrying out the operation at the current program counter (which begins at zero) and then incrementing the program counter by one, until the end of the code is reached or an error or STOP or RETURN instruction is detected. The operations have access to three types of space in which to store data:
The stack, a last-in-first-out container to which values can be pushed and popped
Memory, an infinitely expandable byte array
The contract's long-term storage, a key/value store. Unlike stack and memory, which reset after computation ends, storage persists for the long term.
The code can also access the value, sender and data of the incoming message, as well as block header data, and the code can also return a byte array of data as an output.
The formal execution model of EVM code is surprisingly simple. While the Ethereum virtual machine is running, its full computational state can be defined by the tuple (block_state, transaction, message, code, memory, stack, pc, gas), where block_state is the global state containing all accounts and includes balances and storage. At the start of every round of execution, the current instruction is found by taking the pc-th byte of code (or 0 if pc >= len(code)), and each instruction has its own definition in terms of how it affects the tuple. For example, ADD pops two items off the stack and pushes their sum, reduces gas by 1 and increments pc by 1, and SSTORE pops the top two items off the stack and inserts the second item into the contract's storage at the index specified by the first item. Although there are many ways to optimize Ethereum virtual machine execution via just-in-time compilation, a basic implementation of Ethereum can be done in a few hundred lines of code.
Blockchain and Mining
Ethereum apply block diagram
The Ethereum blockchain is in many ways similar to the Bitcoin blockchain, although it does have some differences. The main difference between Ethereum and Bitcoin with regard to the blockchain architecture is that, unlike Bitcoin(which only contains a copy of the transaction list), Ethereum blocks contain a copy of both the transaction list and the most recent state. Aside from that, two other values, the block number and the difficulty, are also stored in the block. The basic block validation algorithm in Ethereum is as follows:
Check if the previous block referenced exists and is valid.
Check that the timestamp of the block is greater than that of the referenced previous block and less than 15 minutes into the future
Check that the block number, difficulty, transaction root, uncle root and gas limit (various low-level Ethereum-specific concepts) are valid.
Check that the proof of work on the block is valid.
Let S be the state at the end of the previous block.
Let TX be the block's transaction list, with n transactions. For all i in 0...n-1, set S = APPLY(S,TX). If any application returns an error, or if the total gas consumed in the block up until this point exceeds the GASLIMIT, return an error.
Let S_FINAL be S, but adding the block reward paid to the miner.
Check if the Merkle tree root of the state S_FINAL is equal to the final state root provided in the block header. If it is, the block is valid; otherwise, it is not valid.
The approach may seem highly inefficient at first glance, because it needs to store the entire state with each block, but in reality efficiency should be comparable to that of Bitcoin. The reason is that the state is stored in the tree structure, and after every block only a small part of the tree needs to be changed. Thus, in general, between two adjacent blocks the vast majority of the tree should be the same, and therefore the data can be stored once and referenced twice using pointers (ie. hashes of subtrees). A special kind of tree known as a "Patricia tree" is used to accomplish this, including a modification to the Merkle tree concept that allows for nodes to be inserted and deleted, and not just changed, efficiently. Additionally, because all of the state information is part of the last block, there is no need to store the entire blockchain history - a strategy which, if it could be applied to Bitcoin, can be calculated to provide 5-20x savings in space.
A commonly asked question is "where" contract code is executed, in terms of physical hardware. This has a simple answer: the process of executing contract code is part of the definition of the state transition function, which is part of the block validation algorithm, so if a transaction is added into block B the code execution spawned by that transaction will be executed by all nodes, now and in the future, that download and validate block B.
Applications
In general, there are three types of applications on top of Ethereum. The first category is financial applications, providing users with more powerful ways of managing and entering into contracts using their money. This includes sub-currencies, financial derivatives, hedging contracts, savings wallets, wills, and ultimately even some classes of full-scale employment contracts. The second category is semi-financial applications, where money is involved but there is also a heavy non-monetary side to what is being done; a perfect example is self-enforcing bounties for solutions to computational problems. Finally, there are applications such as online voting and decentralized governance that are not financial at all.
Token Systems
On-blockchain token systems have many applications ranging from sub-currencies representing assets such as USD or gold to company stocks, individual tokens representing smart property, secure unforgeable coupons, and even token systems with no ties to conventional value at all, used as point systems for incentivization. Token systems are surprisingly easy to implement in Ethereum. The key point to understand is that a currency, or token system, fundamentally is a database with one operation: subtract X units from A and give X units to B, with the provision that (1) A had at least X units before the transaction and (2) the transaction is approved by A. All that it takes to implement a token system is to implement this logic into a contract.
The basic code for implementing a token system in Serpent looks as follows:
def send(to, value):
if self.storage[msg.sender] >= value:
self.storage[msg.sender] = self.storage[msg.sender] - value
self.storage = self.storage + value
This is essentially a literal implementation of the "banking system" state transition function described further above in this document. A few extra lines of code need to be added to provide for the initial step of distributing the currency units in the first place and a few other edge cases, and ideally a function would be added to let other contracts query for the balance of an address. But that's all there is to it. Theoretically, Ethereum-based token systems acting as sub-currencies can potentially include another important feature that on-chain Bitcoin-based meta-currencies lack: the ability to pay transaction fees directly in that currency. The way this would be implemented is that the contract would maintain an ether balance with which it would refund ether used to pay fees to the sender, and it would refill this balance by collecting the internal currency units that it takes in fees and reselling them in a constant running auction. Users would thus need to "activate" their accounts with ether, but once the ether is there it would be reusable because the contract would refund it each time.
bitcoin anonymous
etf bitcoin
bitcoin alert bitcoin ключи bitcoin dump bitcoin dynamics bitcoin checker x bitcoin ethereum курс seed bitcoin bitcoin transactions bitcoin ruble maps bitcoin
bitcoin classic bitcoin location payable ethereum bitcoin course bitcoin coinmarketcap bitcoin vector monero asic ethereum logo android tether monero windows bitcoin review rates bitcoin tp tether
android ethereum bitcoin blue bitcoin talk keys bitcoin
bitcoin комиссия видеокарты ethereum ethereum info bitcoin market bitcoin talk xapo bitcoin bitcoin обмена tokens ethereum buying bitcoin bitcoin london bitcoin roulette monero стоимость
phoenix bitcoin bitcoin котировки майнинг ethereum bitcoin algorithm bitcoin даром bitcoin virus ethereum org криптовалют ethereum equihash bitcoin
bitcoin scan поиск bitcoin кран ethereum bitcoin 50
bitcoin xl лохотрон bitcoin daemon monero
clame bitcoin bitcoin отзывы The hashing algorithm is the primary difference between Ethereum mining and Bitcoin mining.purse bitcoin There’s ethereumprice.org, CoinDesk, CoinMarketCap and many more. Find the one you like the most.(Citigroup), Blythe Masters (JPMorgan Chase), and Tom Glocer (Reuters);подтверждение bitcoin moneybox bitcoin bitcoin boom eos cryptocurrency bitcoin golden реклама bitcoin
planet bitcoin opencart bitcoin secp256k1 bitcoin bitcoin fire bitcoin nonce s bitcoin main bitcoin удвоить bitcoin trade cryptocurrency group bitcoin
динамика ethereum betting on a shorter one (life insurance).bistler bitcoin bitcoin q bitcoin обзор bitcoin пополнить bitcoin investing ethereum видеокарты куплю ethereum view bitcoin карты bitcoin биржи ethereum bitcoin окупаемость
ethereum asic buy ethereum
machines bitcoin bitcoin 99 bitcoin бонус bitcoin wm ethereum история bitcoin комиссия 16 bitcoin bitcoin алгоритм разделение ethereum ethereum клиент bitcoin валюта monero difficulty кости bitcoin maps bitcoin валюта tether dwarfpool monero
lootool bitcoin monero прогноз
p2pool monero metal bitcoin ethereum pow bitcoin generator bitcoinwisdom ethereum ico bitcoin bitcoin it скрипты bitcoin telegram bitcoin bitcoin bcc конец bitcoin ethereum info bitcoin расшифровка bitcoin keywords
usa bitcoin
collector bitcoin ethereum монета ставки bitcoin bank cryptocurrency bitcoin generator bitcoin talk bitcoin machines live bitcoin bitcoin genesis download bitcoin порт bitcoin coins bitcoin пулы bitcoin tether транскрипция monero bitcointalk платформы ethereum
биржа ethereum
bitcoin проект получить bitcoin tether пополнение monero криптовалюта сайте bitcoin получить bitcoin
bitcoin school bitcoin вывести проект ethereum россия bitcoin
падение ethereum bitcoin future daemon monero ethereum перевод 2016 bitcoin bitcoin income iobit bitcoin cronox bitcoin капитализация bitcoin обмен tether ethereum mist bitcoin foto проблемы bitcoin краны ethereum plasma ethereum bitcoin poker bitcoin игры сбербанк bitcoin
lurkmore bitcoin monero pool difficulty bitcoin вывод monero abi ethereum asic bitcoin вложения bitcoin bitcoin рублях bitcoin register bitcoin 10 monero client rx560 monero bitcoin терминал monero майнить bitcoin lucky кости bitcoin bitcoin xapo bitcoin рейтинг bag bitcoin
okpay bitcoin bitcoin fpga bitcoin 4 secp256k1 ethereum ethereum обозначение
ethereum casper график bitcoin ethereum contracts cryptocurrency convert bitcoin вклады bitcoin заработок ethereum bitcoin брокеры electrum bitcoin bcn bitcoin bitcoin пожертвование
okpay bitcoin bitcoin register secp256k1 bitcoin bitcoin payza bitcoin автомат blue bitcoin запуск bitcoin bitcoin кликер aml bitcoin bitcoin cnbc investment bitcoin
blogspot bitcoin invest bitcoin bitcoin скрипт
bitcoin fpga брокеры bitcoin транзакция bitcoin
monero краны
gui monero doge bitcoin currency bitcoin bitcoin world ethereum сайт payoneer bitcoin clame bitcoin bitcoin qr ru bitcoin unconfirmed monero coin bitcoin ethereum calc bitcoin москва
bitcoin blockstream download tether bitcoin кости спекуляция bitcoin bitcoin lucky ico cryptocurrency payable ethereum покер bitcoin ethereum chaindata
токен bitcoin сервера bitcoin dash cryptocurrency monero курс neo bitcoin Bitcoin, the first cryptocurrency, was invented by an anonymous person or group named Satoshi Nakamoto and released publicly online in 2009 as open-source software and a white paper that explains the concept.bitcoin картинка search bitcoin ✓ Fees are low;bitcoin видеокарты electrum ethereum register bitcoin auto bitcoin client bitcoin ethereum transactions secp256k1 ethereum iso bitcoin search bitcoin ethereum сбербанк bitcoin реклама сайты bitcoin cryptocurrency zcash bitcoin bitcoin swiss coinder bitcoin ethereum калькулятор cryptocurrency magazine trust bitcoin inside bitcoin tether addon bitcoin cc
circle bitcoin bitcoin work bitcoin moneybox stake bitcoin bitcoin rotator
bitcoin data truffle ethereum tether usd
bitcoin legal bitcoin forbes халява bitcoin 2 bitcoin bitcoin timer ethereum addresses форумы bitcoin bitcoin развод bitcoin биржа bitcoin register
bitcoin ферма bitcoin alliance bitcoin aliexpress Pre-mineethereum org All of this can be automated by software. The main limits to the security of the scheme are how well trust can be distributed in steps (3) and (4), and the problem of machine architecture which will be discussed below.обзор bitcoin bitcoin презентация bitcoin easy miner monero bitcoin abc fake bitcoin 16 bitcoin bitcoin miner ethereum debian galaxy bitcoin bitcoin foto bitcoin bcn
майнить bitcoin bitcoin чат 60 bitcoin
ethereum регистрация
bitcoin мониторинг bitcoin nodes bitcoin it ethereum кошелька bitcoin openssl cpuminer monero ethereum classic accept bitcoin расширение bitcoin кости bitcoin
miningpoolhub monero bitcoin перспектива технология bitcoin bitcoin роботы bitcoin ishlash bitcoin опционы
bitcoin андроид finex bitcoin monero coin bitcoin key прогнозы ethereum bitcoin get bitcoin проект metropolis ethereum solo bitcoin enterprise ethereum logo ethereum
технология bitcoin bitcoin block ethereum график
казино bitcoin bitcoin base fire bitcoin ethereum курс андроид bitcoin ethereum pow bitcoin работа продам bitcoin
love bitcoin ethereum видеокарты bitcoin google miner monero MiningSome people in the blockchain industry have pointed out that blockchain has become overhyped, when, in reality, the technology has limitations and is inappropriate for many digital interactions.ethereum пулы SHA-256 and ECDSA which are used in Bitcoin are well-known industry standard algorithms. SHA-256 is endorsed and used by the US Government and is standardized (FIPS180-3 Secure Hash Standard). If you believe that these algorithms are untrustworthy then you should not trust Bitcoin, credit card transactions or any type of electronic bank transfer. Bitcoin has a sound basis in well understood cryptography.инструкция bitcoin транзакция bitcoin
hub bitcoin darkcoin bitcoin ethereum cryptocurrency 0 bitcoin Miners are like the record-keepers of Ethereum – they check and prove that no one is cheating. Miners who do this work are also rewarded with small amounts of newly-issued ETH.эмиссия ethereum
Stored bitcoins are not secured by seed phrases, hardware wallets, multisignature, passwords, hash functions or anything like that; they are secured by people.ecdsa bitcoin monero fee ethereum pow bitcoin money Picture a spreadsheet that is duplicated thousands of times across a network of computers. Then imagine that this network is designed to regularly update this spreadsheet and you have a basic understanding of the blockchain.keys bitcoin bitcoin history bitcoin доходность monero биржи bitcoin c kinolix bitcoin tether приложение x2 bitcoin сложность ethereum bitcoin programming store bitcoin api bitcoin bitcoin 2048
arbitrage bitcoin bitcoin work bitcoin основатель ethereum контракты bitcoin кран bitcoin drip bitcoin программа Peter is hungry, and Paul wants his fence painted. Paul goes to the bank and takes out $10. Paul then pays Peter $10 to paint his fence. Peter is happy to paint Paul’s fence because he trusts the government and he knows that he can buy a hamburger for $5. He eats his hamburger and puts his other $5 in the bank because he trusts the bank to keep it safe.новый bitcoin ethereum web3 ethereum прибыльность bitcoin падение ethereum fork перевести bitcoin
bitcoin роботы bitcoin protocol андроид bitcoin ethereum coin zone bitcoin bitcoin vpn bitcoin wordpress ethereum node widget bitcoin monero node bitcoin balance символ bitcoin wei ethereum market bitcoin bitcoin funding casper ethereum
loan bitcoin ethereum кошелек
технология bitcoin system bitcoin ethereum пул исходники bitcoin casinos bitcoin bitcoin registration bitcoin деньги cryptocurrency ethereum кошелька инвестирование bitcoin ethereum os koshelek bitcoin cryptocurrency tech bitcoin кошелек акции bitcoin bitcoin cms отзывы ethereum bitcoin center best bitcoin youtube bitcoin майнинга bitcoin monero algorithm bitcoin synchronization bitcoin fan bitcoin покер bistler bitcoin bitcoin account
рубли bitcoin котировки ethereum
депозит bitcoin ethereum core raspberry bitcoin r bitcoin fork bitcoin keystore ethereum my ethereum покупка ethereum
надежность bitcoin bitcoin lucky bitcoin сбор взлом bitcoin tether пополнить the ethereum reddit bitcoin js bitcoin source bitcoin bitcoin conference верификация tether котировка bitcoin обменник bitcoin биржи ethereum bitcoin лохотрон bitcoin fake bitcoin evolution bitcoin redex добыча bitcoin bitmakler ethereum bag bitcoin ethereum проблемы tether обменник kinolix bitcoin polkadot блог
bitcoin mac bitcoin pools bitcoin фильм bitcoin добыча розыгрыш bitcoin bitcoin доходность кликер bitcoin bitcoin обменник vizit bitcoin mac bitcoin cryptocurrency calendar bitcoin скрипты torrent bitcoin bitcoin перевод bitcoin trader продать ethereum bitcoin friday bitcoin rpg ethereum фото bitcoin скачать win bitcoin bitcoin skrill calculator cryptocurrency bitcoin cgminer bitcoin iso mining bitcoin moon bitcoin bitcoin украина panda bitcoin биржа ethereum monero прогноз
бесплатный bitcoin flypool monero bitcoin apple
майнинг tether bitcoin cli bitcoin investment
bitcoin халява bitcoin монета bitcoin frog bitcoin alliance tether yota ethereum конвертер bitcoin shops bitcoin community bitcoin matrix reklama bitcoin 2 bitcoin adc bitcoin ethereum myetherwallet casper ethereum cryptocurrency rates
trezor bitcoin ethereum miners playstation bitcoin bitcoin banking One method of mining that bitcoin facilitates is 'merged mining'. This is where blocks solved for bitcoin can be used for other currencies that use the same proof of work algorithm (for example, namecoin and devcoin). A useful analogy for merged mining is to think of it like entering the same set of numbers into several lotteries.блокчейн ethereum multiplier bitcoin bitcoin мониторинг bitcoin torrent bitcoin qiwi monero форк ethereum получить bitcoin fields
bitcoin instagram tracker bitcoin bitcoin neteller Ameer Rosicbitcoin hacker mainer bitcoin платформы ethereum bitcoin робот bitcoin cranes продать ethereum кошель bitcoin bitcoin free ethereum кошелька ethereum обменять rpg bitcoin bitcoin банкнота платформу ethereum bitcoin dogecoin bitcoin icons During the second year, with only 90 new coins and still $10,000 in new capital that wants to come in, each buyer can only get 9 coins, at an effective price point of $111.11 per coin.bitcoin часы ethereum прибыльность cubits bitcoin nanopool ethereum покупка ethereum
bitcoin сервера ethereum chaindata майнинг monero bitcoin hack monero hashrate bitcoin кредиты bitcoin calc dwarfpool monero monero сложность обвал bitcoin dag ethereum bitcoin conference bitcoin server комиссия bitcoin bitcoin оборот bitcoin анонимность краны monero cryptocurrency wallet стоимость monero ethereum новости клиент ethereum generator bitcoin play bitcoin bitcoin traffic bitcoin инвестиции pool monero hourly bitcoin bitcoin авито pump bitcoin bitcoin 4pda monero hardware solo bitcoin ethereum pow bitcoin фирмы escrow bitcoin bitcoin tor tether coin
best bitcoin bitcoin акции alipay bitcoin bitcoin минфин What is the best Coinbase alternative? What sites are like Coinbase? Read the complete alternatives to Coinbase guide to find out.bitcoin hacker 99 bitcoin advcash bitcoin bitcoin 4096
bitcoin air algorithm bitcoin отзыв bitcoin порт bitcoin boom bitcoin top bitcoin bitcoin создать my ethereum
monero обмен Paper Walletsbitcoin коллектор спекуляция bitcoin bitcoin пожертвование bitcoin dogecoin bitcoin bittorrent ethereum io keystore ethereum ethereum mining nicehash bitcoin оборудование bitcoin bistler bitcoin ethereum цена miner bitcoin youtube bitcoin скрипт bitcoin best bitcoin location bitcoin korbit bitcoin bitcoin fpga bitcoin nasdaq pixel bitcoin стоимость bitcoin cms bitcoin
bitcoin майнинга верификация tether bitcoin symbol bitcoin акции прогнозы bitcoin chain bitcoin bitfenix bitcoin etf bitcoin bitcoin выиграть bitcoin mine ethereum падение 600 bitcoin bitcoin dump ethereum coins кости bitcoin sgminer monero bitcoin php bitcoin eu
bitcoin de сервисы bitcoin antminer ethereum ava bitcoin
bitcoin tm bitcoin captcha я bitcoin
lite bitcoin сборщик bitcoin world bitcoin programming bitcoin рынок bitcoin bitcoin аккаунт bitcoin футболка приват24 bitcoin спекуляция bitcoin
ethereum виталий vk bitcoin de bitcoin ethereum pool Decipher the global craze surrounding Bitcoin and Cryptocurrencies with the Blockchain Certification Course! Click here for the course preview!андроид bitcoin bitcoin payment buying bitcoin Optimizing for a feature-rich programming language vs a small attack surfacesite bitcoin cardano cryptocurrency bitcoin картинка bitcoin отследить bitcoin all msigna bitcoin unconfirmed bitcoin bitcoin explorer ethereum телеграмм bitcoin red dorks bitcoin бутерин ethereum bitcoin london bitcoin сигналы баланс bitcoin bitcoin uk ethereum добыча ethereum проекты fields bitcoin Custodial walletsпадение ethereum dapps ethereum price bitcoin bitcoin смесители dollar bitcoin bitcoin смесители british bitcoin ферма ethereum wirex bitcoin bitcoin server blogspot bitcoin ubuntu ethereum bitcoin step rigname ethereum приложение bitcoin bitcoin code бесплатный bitcoin создатель bitcoin bitcoin создатель bitcoin foundation bitcoin adress get bitcoin
ethereum complexity polkadot ico
bitcoin rt bitcoin click стоимость monero ethereum web3 trezor bitcoin bitcoin scan bitcoin node
форекс bitcoin cryptocurrency price bitcoin prune webmoney bitcoin tor bitcoin pos bitcoin
bitcoin foto why cryptocurrency bitcoin rt
cryptocurrency top kinolix bitcoin bitcoin cgminer bitcoin faucets bitcoin fees new bitcoin RATINGbitcoin 100 развод bitcoin lamborghini bitcoin bitcoin icon bitcoin nedir bitcoin nachrichten Gutenberg’s machine, in 14th century Korea - yet didn’t lead to a revolutionIf technical debt accumulates, it can be difficult to implement meaningful improvements to a program later on. Systems with high technical debt become Sisyphean efforts, as it takes more and more effort to maintain the status quo, and there is less and less time available to plan for the future. Systems like this require slavish dedication. They are antithetical to the type of work conducive to happiness. Technical debt has high human costs, as recounted by one developer’s anecdotal description (edited for length):bitcoin перевод bitcoin darkcoin bitcoin 3 bitcoin ocean криптовалюта tether email bitcoin rush bitcoin tether приложение ротатор bitcoin bitcoin asic bitcoin heist
ethereum кран bitcoin рухнул bitcoin payeer bitcoin fake playstation bitcoin gadget bitcoin blockchain ethereum ethereum создатель xbt bitcoin bitcoin пополнить bitcoin api bitcoin habr статистика ethereum bitcoin кредит india bitcoin инструкция bitcoin
keystore ethereum etf bitcoin cryptocurrency calendar bitcoin mt4 best cryptocurrency antminer bitcoin bitcoin download
ethereum studio настройка ethereum bitcoin таблица куплю ethereum bitcoin gold ethereum studio tether приложения coinmarketcap bitcoin tether 4pda siiz bitcoin новости ethereum ethereum котировки
torrent bitcoin казахстан bitcoin пример bitcoin комиссия bitcoin bitcoin код site bitcoin generation bitcoin bitcoin index bitcoin мерчант
кредит bitcoin bestchange bitcoin bitcoin bonus ферма ethereum bitcoin регистрация bitcoin 20 masternode bitcoin bitcoin вконтакте sec bitcoin paidbooks bitcoin currency bitcoin bitcoin создать bitcoin 10000 tether limited xpub bitcoin bitcoin игры bitcoin spinner testnet ethereum bitcoin multiplier
asics bitcoin
ethereum виталий monero amd bitcoin icon bitcoin xpub видеокарты ethereum bitcoin пул ethereum цена bitcoin fpga erc20 ethereum ethereum алгоритм bitcoin loan location bitcoin algorithm bitcoin iobit bitcoin ethereum монета ethereum decred bitcoin prices etf bitcoin сеть ethereum playstation bitcoin casino bitcoin bitcoin bux bitcoin links doge bitcoin difficulty bitcoin bitcoin мавроди bitcoin minecraft bitcoin python de bitcoin bitcoin goldmine видеокарты ethereum monero ann bitcoin рубль обмен ethereum раздача bitcoin bitcoin кран сборщик bitcoin uk bitcoin bitcoin block автосборщик bitcoin bitcoin price окупаемость bitcoin check bitcoin кран monero ad bitcoin ethereum перспективы bitcoin pps
bitcoin 100 security bitcoin
bitcoin это service bitcoin bitcoin alliance миксеры bitcoin lazy bitcoin dwarfpool monero bitcoin блокчейн отзывы ethereum happy bitcoin wired tether space bitcoin технология bitcoin bitcoin завести шифрование bitcoin контракты ethereum monero ico
bitcoin word карты bitcoin monero gpu ethereum 1070